Babe Ruth vs Eddie Plank

Babe RuthNYAEddie PlankPHACareer regular-season comparisonAny two players render on demand

The verdict

Through age 30, Babe Ruth leads Eddie Plank by 78.6 LWAR. Career LWAR: Babe Ruth 189.2 vs Eddie Plank 107.9.

LWAR is era-adjusted: ldWAR is normalized to each season's league average before summing.

Babe Ruth

1914-1935 span | 2503 games | OF
Club NYA
Career LWAR 189.2 | Awards 33 | MVP x1

Eddie Plank

1901-1917 span | 623 games | P
Club PHA
Career LWAR 107.9 | Awards 4 | MVP x0

Through age 30

Cumulative regular-season totals at each age (age as of June 30 of the season). LWAR is era-adjusted.

Age curveCumulative LWAR through age 30

Babe Ruth NYA 115.7Eddie Plank PHA 37.1
Cumulative era-adjusted LWAR at each age. An age with no recorded ldWAR season is left unplotted, matching the blank cell in the table below: unrecorded is never drawn as zero.
AgeBabe Ruth LWAREddie Plank LWARBabe Ruth OPSEddie Plank OPS
190.0.500
206.6.909
2118.3.813
2229.4.828
2337.7.894
2447.9.981
2560.71.101
2675.65.41.168.439
2782.412.41.158.566
2898.419.61.185.527
29112.628.61.195.532
30115.737.11.172.531

Batting (career)

StatBabe RuthEddie Plank
G2503630
AB83981607
R2174130
H2873331
2B50639
3B1367
HR7143
RBI2217122
SB12313
BB206271
SO1330265
BA0.3420.206
OBP0.4740.25
SLG0.690.245
OPS1.1640.495

Pitching (career)

StatBabe RuthEddie Plank
W94326
L46194
G163623
GS148529
SV423
IP1221.14495.2
H9743958
BB4411072
SO4882246
ERA2.282.35
WHIP1.1591.119

Value (LWAR)

StatBabe RuthEddie Plank
Career LWAR189.2107.9
Best season1923: 16.01904: 9.0
LWAR seasons2217
Sources Unrecorded values are left blank, never zero-filled. Any pair of the 21,227 players in the store renders at /vs/<player-a>/<player-b>.