Cy Young vs Walter Johnson

Cy YoungBOSWalter JohnsonWS1Career regular-season comparisonAny two players render on demand

The verdict

Career LWAR: Cy Young 185.7 vs Walter Johnson 179.7.

Cy Young debuted before 1900; the era-adjusted through-age comparison starts with the 1900 season, so this pair is counting stats only.

Cy Young

1890-1911 span | 906 games | P
Club BOS
Career LWAR 185.7 | Awards 3

Walter Johnson

1907-1927 span | 802 games | P
Club WS1
Career LWAR 179.7 | Awards 33 | MVP x2

Through age 30

Cumulative regular-season totals at each age (age as of June 30 of the season). LWAR is era-adjusted.

Age curveCumulative LWAR through age 30

Cy Young BOS 74.7Walter Johnson WS1 111.1
Cumulative era-adjusted LWAR at each age. An age with no recorded ldWAR season is left unplotted, matching the blank cell in the table below: unrecorded is never drawn as zero.
AgeCy Young LWARWalter Johnson LWARCy Young OPSWalter Johnson OPS
202.4.302
218.8.442
2212.3.389
231.924.0.277.423
248.733.0.405.464
2521.448.7.399.519
2632.765.3.436.555
2743.078.7.464.563
2855.491.3.478.575
2967.4102.4.519.579
3074.7111.1.520.588

Batting (career)

StatCy YoungWalter Johnson
G918933
AB29602324
R325241
H623547
2B8794
3B3541
HR1824
RBI290255
SB2913
BB81110
SO381419
BA0.210.235
OBP0.2340.274
SLG0.2820.342
OPS0.5160.616

Pitching (career)

StatCy YoungWalter Johnson
W511417
L315279
G906802
GS815666
SV1834
IP73565914.2
H70924913
BB12171363
SO28033509
ERA2.632.17
WHIP1.131.061

Value (LWAR)

StatCy YoungWalter Johnson
Career LWAR185.7179.7
Best season1901: 15.11913: 16.6
LWAR seasons2221
Sources Unrecorded values are left blank, never zero-filled. Any pair of the 21,227 players in the store renders at /vs/<player-a>/<player-b>.