Honus Wagner vs Ty Cobb

Honus WagnerPITTy CobbDETCareer regular-season comparisonAny two players render on demand

The verdict

Career LWAR: Honus Wagner 121.7 vs Ty Cobb 158.6.

Honus Wagner debuted before 1900; the era-adjusted through-age comparison starts with the 1900 season, so this pair is counting stats only.

Honus Wagner

1897-1917 span | 2794 games | SS
Club PIT
Career LWAR 121.7 | Awards 12 | MVP x0

Ty Cobb

1905-1928 span | 3035 games | OF
Club DET
Career LWAR 158.6 | Awards 31 | MVP x1

Through age 30

Cumulative regular-season totals at each age (age as of June 30 of the season). LWAR is era-adjusted.

Age curveCumulative LWAR through age 30

Honus Wagner PIT 42.7Ty Cobb DET 100.3
Cumulative era-adjusted LWAR at each age. An age with no recorded ldWAR season is left unplotted, matching the blank cell in the table below: unrecorded is never drawn as zero.
AgeHonus Wagner LWARTy Cobb LWARHonus Wagner OPSTy Cobb OPS
190.2.584
203.2.700
2110.3.780
2217.3.802
231.527.4.843.839
243.238.3.778.870
258.049.8.826.908
2614.359.9.876.927
2720.769.1.884.935
2826.976.8.879.938
2933.788.2.886.943
3042.7100.3.894.943

Batting (career)

StatHonus WagnerTy Cobb
G27943035
AB1043911436
R17392247
H34204189
2B643724
3B252295
HR101117
RBI17331944
SB723896
BB9631249
SO735680
BA0.3280.366
OBP0.3910.433
SLG0.4670.512
OPS0.8580.945

Pitching (career)

StatHonus WagnerTy Cobb
W00
L00
G23
GS00
SV01
IP8.15
H76
BB62
SO60
ERA03.6
WHIP1.561.6

Value (LWAR)

StatHonus WagnerTy Cobb
Career LWAR121.7158.6
Best season1908: 12.01917: 13.8
LWAR seasons2124
Sources Unrecorded values are left blank, never zero-filled. Any pair of the 21,227 players in the store renders at /vs/<player-a>/<player-b>.