Lou Gehrig vs Mickey Mantle

Lou GehrigNYAMickey MantleNYACareer regular-season comparisonAny two players render on demand

The verdict

Through age 30, Mickey Mantle leads Lou Gehrig by 15.0 LWAR. Career LWAR: Lou Gehrig 97.1 vs Mickey Mantle 92.3.

LWAR is era-adjusted: ldWAR is normalized to each season's league average before summing. Career wRC+ (also era-adjusted): Lou Gehrig 169 vs Mickey Mantle 168.

Lou Gehrig

1923-1939 span | 2164 games | 1B
Club NYA
Career LWAR 97.1 | Awards 22 | MVP x2

Mickey Mantle

1951-1968 span | 2401 games | OF
Club NYA
Career LWAR 92.3 | Awards 11 | MVP x3

Through age 30

Cumulative regular-season totals at each age (age as of June 30 of the season). LWAR is era-adjusted.

Age curveCumulative LWAR through age 30

Lou Gehrig NYA 61.4Mickey Mantle NYA 76.4
Cumulative era-adjusted LWAR at each age. An age with no recorded ldWAR season is left unplotted, matching the blank cell in the table below: unrecorded is never drawn as zero.
AgeLou Gehrig LWARMickey Mantle LWARLou Gehrig OPSMickey Mantle OPS
200.5-0.31.234.792
210.68.91.198.874
224.813.7.920.881
2310.120.9.948.896
2417.826.41.053.928
2526.838.11.069.972
2633.050.71.0581.002
2740.456.91.0821.006
2848.564.31.086.994
2954.768.21.084.990
3061.476.41.0781.004

Batting (career)

StatLou GehrigMickey Mantle
G21642401
AB80018102
R18881677
H27212415
2B534344
3B16372
HR493536
RBI19951509
SB102153
BB15081733
SO7901710
BA0.340.298
OBP0.4470.421
SLG0.6320.557
OPS1.080.977

Value (LWAR)

StatLou GehrigMickey Mantle
Career LWAR97.192.3
Best season1935: 10.01957: 12.5
LWAR seasons1718
Sources Unrecorded values are left blank, never zero-filled. Any pair of the 21,227 players in the store renders at /vs/<player-a>/<player-b>.