Mickey Mantle vs Willie Mays

Mickey MantleNYAWillie MaysNY1Career regular-season comparisonAny two players render on demand

The verdict

Through age 30, Willie Mays leads Mickey Mantle by 11.4 LWAR. Career LWAR: Mickey Mantle 92.3 vs Willie Mays 148.8.

LWAR is era-adjusted: ldWAR is normalized to each season's league average before summing. Career wRC+ (also era-adjusted): Mickey Mantle 168 vs Willie Mays 154.

Mickey Mantle

1951-1968 span | 2401 games | OF
Club NYA
Career LWAR 92.3 | Awards 11 | MVP x3

Willie Mays

1951-1973 span | 2992 games | OF
Club NY1
Career LWAR 148.8 | Awards 26 | MVP x3

Through age 30

Cumulative regular-season totals at each age (age as of June 30 of the season). LWAR is era-adjusted.

Age curveCumulative LWAR through age 30

Mickey Mantle NYA 76.4Willie Mays NY1 87.8
Cumulative era-adjusted LWAR at each age. An age with no recorded ldWAR season is left unplotted, matching the blank cell in the table below: unrecorded is never drawn as zero.
AgeMickey Mantle LWARWillie Mays LWARMickey Mantle OPSWillie Mays OPS
20-0.35.2.792.828
218.97.5.874.808
2213.77.5.881.808
2320.918.5.896.940
2426.431.5.928.980
2538.143.0.972.966
2650.754.81.002.980
2756.967.31.006.984
2864.371.0.994.981
2968.277.8.990.975
3076.487.81.004.975

Batting (career)

StatMickey MantleWillie Mays
G24012992
AB810210881
R16772062
H24153283
2B344523
3B72140
HR536660
RBI15091903
SB153338
BB17331464
SO17101526
BA0.2980.302
OBP0.4210.384
SLG0.5570.557
OPS0.9770.941

Value (LWAR)

StatMickey MantleWillie Mays
Career LWAR92.3148.8
Best season1957: 12.51955: 13.0
LWAR seasons1822
Sources Unrecorded values are left blank, never zero-filled. Any pair of the 21,227 players in the store renders at /vs/<player-a>/<player-b>.