| 2024 | Kevin Kiermaier | 2024 awards · 2024 postseason |
| 2023 | Andre Lipcius | 2023 awards · 2023 postseason |
| 2023 | Sawyer Gipson-Long | 2023 awards · 2023 postseason |
| 2021 | Asdrubal Cabrera | 2021 awards · 2021 postseason |
| 2021 | Tony Watson | 2021 awards · 2021 postseason |
| 2019 | Adalberto Mejia | 2019 awards · 2019 postseason |
| 2019 | Adam Jones | 2019 awards · 2019 postseason |
| 2019 | Andrew Cashner | 2019 awards · 2019 postseason |
| 2019 | Bobby Poyner | 2019 awards · 2019 postseason |
| 2019 | Buddy Boshers | 2019 awards · 2019 postseason |
| 2019 | Corban Joseph | 2019 awards · 2019 postseason |
| 2019 | Dan Otero | 2019 awards · 2019 postseason |
| 2019 | David Freese | 2019 awards · 2019 postseason |
| 2019 | Edwin Jackson | 2019 awards · 2019 postseason |
| 2019 | Fernando Rodney | 2019 awards · 2019 postseason |
| 2019 | Gordon Beckham | 2019 awards · 2019 postseason |
| 2019 | James Marvel | 2019 awards · 2019 postseason |
| 2019 | Keon Broxton | 2019 awards · 2019 postseason |
| 2019 | Matt Albers | 2019 awards · 2019 postseason |
| 2019 | Russell Martin | 2019 awards · 2019 postseason |
| 2019 | Sam Travis | 2019 awards · 2019 postseason |
| 2019 | Sam Tuivailala | 2019 awards · 2019 postseason |
| 2019 | Seth Mejias-Brean | 2019 awards · 2019 postseason |
| 2019 | Steven Baron | 2019 awards · 2019 postseason |
| 2019 | Tayron Guerrero | 2019 awards · 2019 postseason |
| 2019 | Wei-Yin Chen | 2019 awards · 2019 postseason |
| 2019 | Williams Jerez | 2019 awards · 2019 postseason |
| 2018 | Bud Norris | 2018 awards · 2018 postseason |
| 2018 | CD Pelham | 2018 awards · 2018 postseason |
| 2018 | Dean Kiekhefer | 2018 awards · 2018 postseason |
| 2018 | Eddie Butler | 2018 awards · 2018 postseason |
| 2018 | Jesus Reyes | 2018 awards · 2018 postseason |
| 2018 | Randall Delgado | 2018 awards · 2018 postseason |
| 2018 | Rob Scahill | 2018 awards · 2018 postseason |
| 2018 | Sammy Solis | 2018 awards · 2018 postseason |
| 2018 | Vidal Nuno | 2018 awards · 2018 postseason |
| 2018 | William Cuevas | 2018 awards · 2018 postseason |
| 2017 | Austin Maddox | 2017 awards · 2017 postseason |
| 2017 | Craig Breslow | 2017 awards · 2017 postseason |
| 2016 | Brett Wallace | 2016 awards · 2016 postseason |
| 2016 | Emmanuel Burriss | 2016 awards · 2016 postseason |
| 2016 | Joe Colon | 2016 awards · 2016 postseason |
| 2016 | Matt McBride | 2016 awards · 2016 postseason |
| 2014 | Aaron Crow | 2014 awards · 2014 postseason |
| 2014 | Adam Dunn | 2014 awards · 2014 postseason |
| 2014 | Antoan Richardson | 2014 awards · 2014 postseason |
| 2014 | Bobby Abreu | 2014 awards · 2014 postseason |
| 2014 | Casey Coleman | 2014 awards · 2014 postseason |
| 2014 | Chris Valaika | 2014 awards · 2014 postseason |
| 2014 | Dayan Viciedo | 2014 awards · 2014 postseason |
| 2014 | Derek Jeter | 2014 awards · 2014 postseason |
| 2014 | Drake Britton | 2014 awards · 2014 postseason |
| 2014 | Erisbel Arruebarrena | 2014 awards · 2014 postseason |
| 2014 | Gaby Sanchez | 2014 awards · 2014 postseason |
| 2014 | Gary Brown | 2014 awards · 2014 postseason |
| 2014 | George Kottaras | 2014 awards · 2014 postseason |
| 2014 | Jayson Nix | 2014 awards · 2014 postseason |
| 2014 | Jeff Kobernus | 2014 awards · 2014 postseason |
| 2014 | John Baker | 2014 awards · 2014 postseason |
| 2014 | John Buck | 2014 awards · 2014 postseason |
| 2014 | John McDonald | 2014 awards · 2014 postseason |
| 2014 | Jorge De Leon | 2014 awards · 2014 postseason |
| 2014 | Jose Molina | 2014 awards · 2014 postseason |
| 2014 | Josh Willingham | 2014 awards · 2014 postseason |
| 2014 | Juan Francisco | 2014 awards · 2014 postseason |
| 2014 | Lester Oliveros | 2014 awards · 2014 postseason |
| 2014 | Logan Watkins | 2014 awards · 2014 postseason |
| 2014 | Lyle Overbay | 2014 awards · 2014 postseason |
| 2014 | Matt Clark | 2014 awards · 2014 postseason |
| 2014 | Michael Taylor | 2014 awards · 2014 postseason |
| 2014 | Nate Schierholtz | 2014 awards · 2014 postseason |
| 2014 | Oscar Taveras | 2014 awards · 2014 postseason |
| 2014 | Paul Konerko | 2014 awards · 2014 postseason |
| 2014 | Raul Ibanez | 2014 awards · 2014 postseason |
| 2014 | Roger Bernadina | 2014 awards · 2014 postseason |
| 2014 | Ryan Doumit | 2014 awards · 2014 postseason |
| 2014 | Scott Hairston | 2014 awards · 2014 postseason |
| 2014 | Tommy Medica | 2014 awards · 2014 postseason |
| 2014 | Tony Campana | 2014 awards · 2014 postseason |
| 2014 | Tony Gwynn | 2014 awards · 2014 postseason |
| 2014 | Yorman Rodriguez | 2014 awards · 2014 postseason |
| 2014 | Yoslan Herrera | 2014 awards · 2014 postseason |
| 2013 | Andy Pettitte | 2013 awards · 2013 postseason |
| 2013 | Brett Pill | 2013 awards · 2013 postseason |
| 2013 | Casper Wells | 2013 awards · 2013 postseason |
| 2013 | Chad Tracy | 2013 awards · 2013 postseason |
| 2013 | Chance Ruffin | 2013 awards · 2013 postseason |
| 2013 | Chia-Jen Lo | 2013 awards · 2013 postseason |
| 2013 | Chris Dwyer | 2013 awards · 2013 postseason |
| 2013 | Chris Robinson | 2013 awards · 2013 postseason |
| 2013 | Chris Snyder | 2013 awards · 2013 postseason |
| 2013 | Cole De Vries | 2013 awards · 2013 postseason |
| 2013 | Jarrod Parker | 2013 awards · 2013 postseason |
| 2013 | Jose Mijares | 2013 awards · 2013 postseason |
| 2013 | Kameron Loe | 2013 awards · 2013 postseason |
| 2013 | Michael Stutes | 2013 awards · 2013 postseason |
| 2013 | Miguel Gonzalez | 2013 awards · 2013 postseason |
| 2013 | Mike Gonzalez | 2013 awards · 2013 postseason |
| 2013 | Pedro Feliciano | 2013 awards · 2013 postseason |
| 2013 | Placido Polanco | 2013 awards · 2013 postseason |
| 2013 | Robert Coello | 2013 awards · 2013 postseason |
| 2013 | Tommy Hanson | 2013 awards · 2013 postseason |
| 2013 | Zach Lutz | 2013 awards · 2013 postseason |
| 2012 | Aaron Cook | 2012 awards · 2012 postseason |
| 2012 | Jeff Clement | 2012 awards · 2012 postseason |
| 2012 | Joel Carreno | 2012 awards · 2012 postseason |
| 2012 | Luis Martinez | 2012 awards · 2012 postseason |
| 2011 | Alex Cora | 2011 awards · 2011 postseason |
| 2011 | Andrew Brackman | 2011 awards · 2011 postseason |
| 2011 | Anthony Vasquez | 2011 awards · 2011 postseason |
| 2011 | Brian Burres | 2011 awards · 2011 postseason |
| 2011 | Brian Dinkelman | 2011 awards · 2011 postseason |
| 2011 | Craig Counsell | 2011 awards · 2011 postseason |
| 2011 | Daniel Moskos | 2011 awards · 2011 postseason |
| 2011 | Derrek Lee | 2011 awards · 2011 postseason |
| 2011 | Donny Lucy | 2011 awards · 2011 postseason |
| 2011 | Edgar Renteria | 2011 awards · 2011 postseason |
| 2011 | Eugenio Velez | 2011 awards · 2011 postseason |
| 2011 | Greg Golson | 2011 awards · 2011 postseason |
| 2011 | Ivan Rodriguez | 2011 awards · 2011 postseason |
| 2011 | J. D. Drew | 2011 awards · 2011 postseason |
| 2011 | Jai Miller | 2011 awards · 2011 postseason |
| 2011 | Jason Jaramillo | 2011 awards · 2011 postseason |
| 2011 | Jeremy Moore | 2011 awards · 2011 postseason |
| 2011 | Joe Benson | 2011 awards · 2011 postseason |
| 2011 | Joey Gathright | 2011 awards · 2011 postseason |
| 2011 | Jorge Posada | 2011 awards · 2011 postseason |
| 2011 | Kyle Hudson | 2011 awards · 2011 postseason |
| 2011 | Lance Pendleton | 2011 awards · 2011 postseason |
| 2011 | Landon Powell | 2011 awards · 2011 postseason |
| 2011 | Luis Montanez | 2011 awards · 2011 postseason |
| 2011 | Mark Teahen | 2011 awards · 2011 postseason |
| 2011 | Matt Angle | 2011 awards · 2011 postseason |
| 2011 | Pat Burrell | 2011 awards · 2011 postseason |
| 2011 | Rene Tosoni | 2011 awards · 2011 postseason |
| 2011 | Robby Hammock | 2011 awards · 2011 postseason |
| 2011 | Scott Linebrink | 2011 awards · 2011 postseason |
| 2011 | Scott Proctor | 2011 awards · 2011 postseason |
| 2011 | Trent Oeltjen | 2011 awards · 2011 postseason |
| 2011 | Vladimir Guerrero | 2011 awards · 2011 postseason |
| 2011 | Willie Eyre | 2011 awards · 2011 postseason |
| 2010 | Matt Fox | 2010 awards · 2010 postseason |
| 2008 | Adam Pettyjohn | 2008 awards · 2008 postseason |
| 2008 | Brad Wilkerson | 2008 awards · 2008 postseason |
| 2008 | Brandon Duckworth | 2008 awards · 2008 postseason |
| 2008 | Brandon Fahey | 2008 awards · 2008 postseason |
| 2008 | Cha-Seung Baek | 2008 awards · 2008 postseason |
| 2008 | Chip Ambres | 2008 awards · 2008 postseason |
| 2008 | Damion Easley | 2008 awards · 2008 postseason |
| 2008 | Darrell Rasner | 2008 awards · 2008 postseason |
| 2008 | Dave Roberts | 2008 awards · 2008 postseason |
| 2008 | David Newhan | 2008 awards · 2008 postseason |
| 2008 | Devern Hansack | 2008 awards · 2008 postseason |
| 2008 | Devon Lowery | 2008 awards · 2008 postseason |
| 2008 | Geoff Jenkins | 2008 awards · 2008 postseason |
| 2008 | German Duran | 2008 awards · 2008 postseason |
| 2008 | Ivan Ochoa | 2008 awards · 2008 postseason |
| 2008 | Javier Valentin | 2008 awards · 2008 postseason |
| 2008 | Jeff Baisley | 2008 awards · 2008 postseason |
| 2008 | Jolbert Cabrera | 2008 awards · 2008 postseason |
| 2008 | Jose Castillo | 2008 awards · 2008 postseason |
| 2008 | Josh Phelps | 2008 awards · 2008 postseason |
| 2008 | Kelvin Jimenez | 2008 awards · 2008 postseason |
| 2008 | Kory Casto | 2008 awards · 2008 postseason |
| 2008 | Les Walrond | 2008 awards · 2008 postseason |
| 2008 | Luis Gonzalez | 2008 awards · 2008 postseason |
| 2008 | Mark Saccomanno | 2008 awards · 2008 postseason |
| 2008 | Matt Antonelli | 2008 awards · 2008 postseason |
| 2008 | Matthew Brown | 2008 awards · 2008 postseason |
| 2008 | Mike Cervenak | 2008 awards · 2008 postseason |
| 2008 | Mike Mussina | 2008 awards · 2008 postseason |
| 2008 | Mike Timlin | 2008 awards · 2008 postseason |
| 2008 | Odalis Perez | 2008 awards · 2008 postseason |
| 2008 | Pablo Ozuna | 2008 awards · 2008 postseason |
| 2008 | Randor Bierd | 2008 awards · 2008 postseason |
| 2008 | Ray Durham | 2008 awards · 2008 postseason |
| 2008 | Reggie Abercrombie | 2008 awards · 2008 postseason |
| 2008 | Ruben Gotay | 2008 awards · 2008 postseason |
| 2008 | Rudy Seanez | 2008 awards · 2008 postseason |
| 2008 | Sean Casey | 2008 awards · 2008 postseason |
| 2008 | T. J. Beam | 2008 awards · 2008 postseason |
| 2008 | Tadahito Iguchi | 2008 awards · 2008 postseason |
| 2007 | Arnie Munoz | 2007 awards · 2007 postseason |
| 2007 | Brad Salmon | 2007 awards · 2007 postseason |
| 2007 | Byung-Hyun Kim | 2007 awards · 2007 postseason |
| 2007 | David Wells | 2007 awards · 2007 postseason |
| 2007 | John Rheinecker | 2007 awards · 2007 postseason |
| 2007 | Jon Leicester | 2007 awards · 2007 postseason |
| 2007 | Marcus Giles | 2007 awards · 2007 postseason |
| 2007 | Marcus McBeth | 2007 awards · 2007 postseason |
| 2007 | Mike Wood | 2007 awards · 2007 postseason |
| 2007 | Scott Munter | 2007 awards · 2007 postseason |
| 2007 | Steve Randolph | 2007 awards · 2007 postseason |
| 2006 | Alexis Gomez | 2006 awards · 2006 postseason |
| 2006 | Antonio Perez | 2006 awards · 2006 postseason |
| 2006 | Brad Radke | 2006 awards · 2006 postseason |
| 2006 | Manny Alexander | 2006 awards · 2006 postseason |
| 2006 | Vance Wilson | 2006 awards · 2006 postseason |
| 2006 | Vinny Castilla | 2006 awards · 2006 postseason |
| 2005 | Brian Cooper | 2005 awards · 2005 postseason |
| 2005 | Chris Magruder | 2005 awards · 2005 postseason |
| 2005 | Craig Dingman | 2005 awards · 2005 postseason |
| 2005 | Denny Hocking | 2005 awards · 2005 postseason |
| 2005 | Jason Karnuth | 2005 awards · 2005 postseason |
| 2005 | Jim Mecir | 2005 awards · 2005 postseason |
| 2005 | Kazuhisa Ishii | 2005 awards · 2005 postseason |
| 2005 | Matt Kinney | 2005 awards · 2005 postseason |
| 2005 | Miguel Perez | 2005 awards · 2005 postseason |
| 2005 | Sean Douglass | 2005 awards · 2005 postseason |
| 2005 | Shigetoshi Hasegawa | 2005 awards · 2005 postseason |
| 2005 | Trent Durrington | 2005 awards · 2005 postseason |
| 2005 | Vic Darensbourg | 2005 awards · 2005 postseason |
| 2005 | Wilson Alvarez | 2005 awards · 2005 postseason |
| 2004 | Danny Bautista | 2004 awards · 2004 postseason |
| 2004 | Shane Nance | 2004 awards · 2004 postseason |
| 2003 | Aaron Looper | 2003 awards · 2003 postseason |
| 2003 | Adam Johnson | 2003 awards · 2003 postseason |
| 2003 | Angel Santos | 2003 awards · 2003 postseason |
| 2003 | Barry Wesson | 2003 awards · 2003 postseason |
| 2003 | Ben Petrick | 2003 awards · 2003 postseason |
| 2003 | Brian Banks | 2003 awards · 2003 postseason |
| 2003 | Carlos Mendez | 2003 awards · 2003 postseason |
| 2003 | Chad Meyers | 2003 awards · 2003 postseason |
| 2003 | Chris Mears | 2003 awards · 2003 postseason |
| 2003 | Dan Plesac | 2003 awards · 2003 postseason |
| 2003 | Dernell Stenson | 2003 awards · 2003 postseason |
| 2003 | Drew Henson | 2003 awards · 2003 postseason |
| 2003 | Edwards Guzman | 2003 awards · 2003 postseason |
| 2003 | Felix Jose | 2003 awards · 2003 postseason |
| 2003 | Fernando Seguignol | 2003 awards · 2003 postseason |
| 2003 | Graham Koonce | 2003 awards · 2003 postseason |
| 2003 | Hector Almonte | 2003 awards · 2003 postseason |
| 2003 | Jarrod Patterson | 2003 awards · 2003 postseason |
| 2003 | Jason Jones | 2003 awards · 2003 postseason |
| 2003 | Jay Bell | 2003 awards · 2003 postseason |
| 2003 | Joe Girardi | 2003 awards · 2003 postseason |
| 2003 | Joe Vitiello | 2003 awards · 2003 postseason |
| 2003 | Jose Morban | 2003 awards · 2003 postseason |
| 2003 | Juan Cerros | 2003 awards · 2003 postseason |
| 2003 | Julius Matos | 2003 awards · 2003 postseason |
| 2003 | Kazuhiro Sasaki | 2003 awards · 2003 postseason |
| 2003 | Luis Martinez | 2003 awards · 2003 postseason |
| 2003 | Luis Sojo | 2003 awards · 2003 postseason |
| 2003 | Mark Grace | 2003 awards · 2003 postseason |
| 2003 | Mark Guthrie | 2003 awards · 2003 postseason |
| 2003 | Mark Smith | 2003 awards · 2003 postseason |
| 2003 | Matt Walbeck | 2003 awards · 2003 postseason |
| 2003 | Mike Bordick | 2003 awards · 2003 postseason |
| 2003 | Mike Glavine | 2003 awards · 2003 postseason |
| 2003 | Mike Kinkade | 2003 awards · 2003 postseason |
| 2003 | Mike Williams | 2003 awards · 2003 postseason |
| 2003 | Orlando Merced | 2003 awards · 2003 postseason |
| 2003 | Peter Zoccolillo | 2003 awards · 2003 postseason |
| 2003 | Prentice Redman | 2003 awards · 2003 postseason |
| 2003 | Ron Coomer | 2003 awards · 2003 postseason |
| 2003 | Ruben Quevedo | 2003 awards · 2003 postseason |
| 2003 | Ryan Christenson | 2003 awards · 2003 postseason |
| 2003 | Scott Randall | 2003 awards · 2003 postseason |
| 2003 | Terry Shumpert | 2003 awards · 2003 postseason |
| 2003 | Tom Prince | 2003 awards · 2003 postseason |
| 2003 | Troy O'Leary | 2003 awards · 2003 postseason |
| 2003 | Warren Morris | 2003 awards · 2003 postseason |
| 2003 | Wilkin Ruan | 2003 awards · 2003 postseason |
| 2002 | Ben Kozlowski | 2002 awards · 2002 postseason |
| 2002 | Brian Lesher | 2002 awards · 2002 postseason |
| 2002 | Chris Brock | 2002 awards · 2002 postseason |
| 2002 | Chuck Finley | 2002 awards · 2002 postseason |
| 2002 | Doug Nickle | 2002 awards · 2002 postseason |
| 2002 | Jason Beverlin | 2002 awards · 2002 postseason |
| 2002 | Jason Jimenez | 2002 awards · 2002 postseason |
| 2002 | Jeff Farnsworth | 2002 awards · 2002 postseason |
| 2002 | Jeff Williams | 2002 awards · 2002 postseason |
| 2002 | Jose Rijo | 2002 awards · 2002 postseason |
| 2002 | Jose Silva | 2002 awards · 2002 postseason |
| 2002 | Kevin Beirne | 2002 awards · 2002 postseason |
| 2002 | Mark Wohlers | 2002 awards · 2002 postseason |
| 2002 | Mike Benjamin | 2002 awards · 2002 postseason |
| 2002 | Mike Fyhrie | 2002 awards · 2002 postseason |
| 2002 | Oswaldo Mairena | 2002 awards · 2002 postseason |
| 2002 | Robb Nen | 2002 awards · 2002 postseason |
| 2002 | Tom Lampkin | 2002 awards · 2002 postseason |
| 2002 | Wayne Gomes | 2002 awards · 2002 postseason |
| 2001 | Bill Ortega | 2001 awards · 2001 postseason |
| 2001 | Felipe Crespo | 2001 awards · 2001 postseason |
| 2001 | Keith McDonald | 2001 awards · 2001 postseason |
| 2001 | Omar Olivares | 2001 awards · 2001 postseason |
| 2000 | Craig House | 2000 awards · 2000 postseason |
| 2000 | David Moraga | 2000 awards · 2000 postseason |
| 2000 | Jay Spurgeon | 2000 awards · 2000 postseason |
| 2000 | Joey Nation | 2000 awards · 2000 postseason |
| 2000 | Kevin McGlinchy | 2000 awards · 2000 postseason |
| 2000 | Mike Sirotka | 2000 awards · 2000 postseason |
| 2000 | Paul Spoljaric | 2000 awards · 2000 postseason |
| 2000 | Rafael Roque | 2000 awards · 2000 postseason |
| 2000 | Scott Karl | 2000 awards · 2000 postseason |
| 2000 | Sean Spencer | 2000 awards · 2000 postseason |
| 1999 | Tim Spehr | 1999 awards · 1999 postseason |
| 1998 | Joe Carter | 1998 awards · 1998 postseason |
| 1997 | Andy Stewart | 1997 awards · 1997 postseason |
| 1997 | Arquimedez Pozo | 1997 awards · 1997 postseason |
| 1997 | Brett Butler | 1997 awards · 1997 postseason |
| 1997 | Brian Raabe | 1997 awards · 1997 postseason |
| 1997 | Damon Berryhill | 1997 awards · 1997 postseason |
| 1997 | Dan Rohrmeier | 1997 awards · 1997 postseason |
| 1997 | Darren Daulton | 1997 awards · 1997 postseason |
| 1997 | Garey Ingram | 1997 awards · 1997 postseason |
| 1997 | Harvey Pulliam | 1997 awards · 1997 postseason |
| 1997 | Jimmy Hurst | 1997 awards · 1997 postseason |
| 1997 | Kevin Seitzer | 1997 awards · 1997 postseason |
| 1997 | Lee Tinsley | 1997 awards · 1997 postseason |
| 1997 | Mark Davis | 1997 awards · 1997 postseason |
| 1997 | Melvin Rosario | 1997 awards · 1997 postseason |
| 1997 | Mike Bovee | 1997 awards · 1997 postseason |
| 1997 | Mike Harkey | 1997 awards · 1997 postseason |
| 1997 | Pete Rose | 1997 awards · 1997 postseason |
| 1997 | Phil Plantier | 1997 awards · 1997 postseason |
| 1997 | Rene Gonzales | 1997 awards · 1997 postseason |
| 1997 | Robert Eenhoorn | 1997 awards · 1997 postseason |
| 1997 | Rod Myers | 1997 awards · 1997 postseason |
| 1997 | Ron Blazier | 1997 awards · 1997 postseason |
| 1997 | Ryne Sandberg | 1997 awards · 1997 postseason |
| 1997 | Scott Cooper | 1997 awards · 1997 postseason |
| 1997 | Tilson Brito | 1997 awards · 1997 postseason |
| 1997 | Tommy Gregg | 1997 awards · 1997 postseason |
| 1997 | Tony Barron | 1997 awards · 1997 postseason |
| 1997 | Tony Peña | 1997 awards · 1997 postseason |
| 1996 | Bill Hurst | 1996 awards · 1996 postseason |
| 1996 | Dax Jones | 1996 awards · 1996 postseason |
| 1996 | Jayhawk Owens | 1996 awards · 1996 postseason |
| 1996 | Jeff Parrett | 1996 awards · 1996 postseason |
| 1996 | Jerry Brooks | 1996 awards · 1996 postseason |
| 1996 | Kevin Lomon | 1996 awards · 1996 postseason |
| 1996 | Kim Batiste | 1996 awards · 1996 postseason |
| 1996 | Luis Ortiz | 1996 awards · 1996 postseason |
| 1996 | Mike Dyer | 1996 awards · 1996 postseason |
| 1996 | Mike Greenwell | 1996 awards · 1996 postseason |
| 1996 | Rick Huisman | 1996 awards · 1996 postseason |
| 1996 | Roger Salkeld | 1996 awards · 1996 postseason |
| 1996 | Steve Bourgeois | 1996 awards · 1996 postseason |
| 1995 | Craig McMurtry | 1995 awards · 1995 postseason |
| 1995 | Kirby Puckett | 1995 awards · 1995 postseason |
| 1995 | Steve Dunn | 1995 awards · 1995 postseason |
| 1993 | Matt Maysey | 1993 awards · 1993 postseason |
| 1993 | Paul Miller | 1993 awards · 1993 postseason |
| 1993 | Tim Teufel | 1993 awards · 1993 postseason |
| 1992 | Cliff Brantley | 1992 awards · 1992 postseason |
| 1992 | Daryl Irvine | 1992 awards · 1992 postseason |
| 1992 | Jeff Hartsock | 1992 awards · 1992 postseason |
| 1992 | Jessie Hollins | 1992 awards · 1992 postseason |
| 1992 | Joe Vitko | 1992 awards · 1992 postseason |
| 1992 | Jorge Pedre | 1992 awards · 1992 postseason |
| 1991 | Jeff Hamilton | 1991 awards · 1991 postseason |
| 1990 | Carlos Diaz | 1990 awards · 1990 postseason |
| 1990 | Edgar Diaz | 1990 awards · 1990 postseason |
| 1990 | Narciso Elvira | 1990 awards · 1990 postseason |
| 1990 | Tim Drummond | 1990 awards · 1990 postseason |
| 1989 | Mike Smithson | 1989 awards · 1989 postseason |
| 1988 | Jeff Heathcock | 1988 awards · 1988 postseason |
| 1988 | Jerry Royster | 1988 awards · 1988 postseason |
| 1988 | Jim Morrison | 1988 awards · 1988 postseason |
| 1988 | Steve Henderson | 1988 awards · 1988 postseason |
| 1988 | Willie Upshaw | 1988 awards · 1988 postseason |
| 1987 | Bill Fulton | 1987 awards · 1987 postseason |
| 1987 | Johnny Grubb | 1987 awards · 1987 postseason |
| 1986 | Brad Gulden | 1986 awards · 1986 postseason |
| 1986 | Jeff Hearron | 1986 awards · 1986 postseason |
| 1986 | Jim Slaton | 1986 awards · 1986 postseason |
| 1986 | Mickey Mahler | 1986 awards · 1986 postseason |
| 1985 | Bruce Tanner | 1985 awards · 1985 postseason |
| 1985 | German Rivera | 1985 awards · 1985 postseason |
| 1984 | Ed Hodge | 1984 awards · 1984 postseason |
| 1984 | Jerry Ujdur | 1984 awards · 1984 postseason |
| 1984 | John Curtis | 1984 awards · 1984 postseason |
| 1984 | Rich Gale | 1984 awards · 1984 postseason |
| 1984 | Tony Brizzolara | 1984 awards · 1984 postseason |
| 1983 | Bobby Bonner | 1983 awards · 1983 postseason |
| 1983 | Jerry Morales | 1983 awards · 1983 postseason |
| 1982 | Jim Smith | 1982 awards · 1982 postseason |
| 1982 | John Mayberry | 1982 awards · 1982 postseason |
| 1982 | Terry Felton | 1982 awards · 1982 postseason |
| 1981 | Gary Alexander | 1981 awards · 1981 postseason |
| 1981 | Mark Mercer | 1981 awards · 1981 postseason |
| 1981 | Neil Fiala | 1981 awards · 1981 postseason |
| 1980 | Craig Chamberlain | 1980 awards · 1980 postseason |
| 1980 | Jack Brohamer | 1980 awards · 1980 postseason |
| 1980 | Mike Edwards | 1980 awards · 1980 postseason |
| 1979 | Buddy Schultz | 1979 awards · 1979 postseason |
| 1979 | Butch Edge | 1979 awards · 1979 postseason |
| 1979 | Craig Eaton | 1979 awards · 1979 postseason |
| 1979 | Dan O'Brien | 1979 awards · 1979 postseason |
| 1979 | Jim Todd | 1979 awards · 1979 postseason |
| 1979 | Paul Reuschel | 1979 awards · 1979 postseason |
| 1979 | Roger Freed | 1979 awards · 1979 postseason |
| 1979 | Sergio Ferrer | 1979 awards · 1979 postseason |
| 1979 | Tim Johnson | 1979 awards · 1979 postseason |
| 1979 | Tom Bruno | 1979 awards · 1979 postseason |
| 1978 | Butch Alberts | 1978 awards · 1978 postseason |
| 1978 | Jim Umbarger | 1978 awards · 1978 postseason |
| 1978 | Jim Willoughby | 1978 awards · 1978 postseason |
| 1978 | Mickey Stanley | 1978 awards · 1978 postseason |
| 1977 | Gary Lance | 1977 awards · 1977 postseason |
| 1976 | Billy Baldwin | 1976 awards · 1976 postseason |
| 1976 | Clay Kirby | 1976 awards · 1976 postseason |
| 1976 | Joe Keener | 1976 awards · 1976 postseason |
| 1976 | Ted Kubiak | 1976 awards · 1976 postseason |
| 1975 | Bob Allietta | 1975 awards · 1975 postseason |
| 1975 | Bobby Mitchell | 1975 awards · 1975 postseason |
| 1975 | Cecil Upshaw | 1975 awards · 1975 postseason |
| 1975 | Dal Maxvill | 1975 awards · 1975 postseason |
| 1975 | Dick Sharon | 1975 awards · 1975 postseason |
| 1975 | Don DeMola | 1975 awards · 1975 postseason |
| 1975 | Ed Brinkman | 1975 awards · 1975 postseason |
| 1975 | Fred Beene | 1975 awards · 1975 postseason |
| 1975 | Jake Brown | 1975 awards · 1975 postseason |
| 1975 | Jim Hutto | 1975 awards · 1975 postseason |
| 1975 | Jim Strickland | 1975 awards · 1975 postseason |
| 1975 | Joe Pactwa | 1975 awards · 1975 postseason |
| 1975 | John Balaz | 1975 awards · 1975 postseason |
| 1975 | John Briggs | 1975 awards · 1975 postseason |
| 1975 | Mike Poepping | 1975 awards · 1975 postseason |
| 1975 | Mike Rogodzinski | 1975 awards · 1975 postseason |
| 1975 | Morris Nettles | 1975 awards · 1975 postseason |
| 1975 | Rick Bladt | 1975 awards · 1975 postseason |
| 1975 | Tom Hilgendorf | 1975 awards · 1975 postseason |
| 1975 | Tom Lundstedt | 1975 awards · 1975 postseason |
| 1975 | Vada Pinson | 1975 awards · 1975 postseason |
| 1974 | Bill Parsons | 1974 awards · 1974 postseason |
| 1974 | Bob Miller | 1974 awards · 1974 postseason |
| 1974 | Bruce Ellingsen | 1974 awards · 1974 postseason |
| 1974 | Chris Cannizzaro | 1974 awards · 1974 postseason |
| 1974 | Don Wilson | 1974 awards · 1974 postseason |
| 1974 | Pat Bourque | 1974 awards · 1974 postseason |
| 1974 | Randy Sterling | 1974 awards · 1974 postseason |
| 1974 | Ron Hunt | 1974 awards · 1974 postseason |
| 1973 | Aurelio Monteagudo | 1973 awards · 1973 postseason |
| 1973 | Hank Allen | 1973 awards · 1973 postseason |
| 1973 | Jim McGlothlin | 1973 awards · 1973 postseason |
| 1973 | Luis Aparicio | 1973 awards · 1973 postseason |
| 1973 | Ray Lamb | 1973 awards · 1973 postseason |
| 1973 | Ron Lolich | 1973 awards · 1973 postseason |
| 1973 | Steve Hovley | 1973 awards · 1973 postseason |
| 1972 | Gary Waslewski | 1972 awards · 1972 postseason |
| 1971 | Bob Aspromonte | 1971 awards · 1971 postseason |
| 1971 | Chuck Hinton | 1971 awards · 1971 postseason |
| 1971 | Dick Kelley | 1971 awards · 1971 postseason |
| 1971 | Hal Haydel | 1971 awards · 1971 postseason |
| 1971 | Sandy Valdespino | 1971 awards · 1971 postseason |
| 1971 | Stan Swanson | 1971 awards · 1971 postseason |
| 1971 | Woody Woodward | 1971 awards · 1971 postseason |
| 1971 | Zoilo Versalles | 1971 awards · 1971 postseason |
| 1969 | Bubba Morton | 1969 awards · 1969 postseason |
| 1969 | Cap Peterson | 1969 awards · 1969 postseason |
| 1969 | Frankie Libran | 1969 awards · 1969 postseason |
| 1969 | Fred Rath | 1969 awards · 1969 postseason |
| 1969 | Ruben Amaro | 1969 awards · 1969 postseason |
| 1969 | Woodie Held | 1969 awards · 1969 postseason |
| 1968 | Bill Kelso | 1968 awards · 1968 postseason |
| 1968 | Dave Adlesh | 1968 awards · 1968 postseason |
| 1968 | Dick Hughes | 1968 awards · 1968 postseason |
| 1968 | Jerry Buchek | 1968 awards · 1968 postseason |
| 1968 | Jon Warden | 1968 awards · 1968 postseason |
| 1968 | Mickey Mantle | 1968 awards · 1968 postseason |
| 1968 | Rocky Colavito | 1968 awards · 1968 postseason |
| 1967 | Ed Rakow | 1967 awards · 1967 postseason |
| 1966 | Ron Campbell | 1966 awards · 1966 postseason |
| 1965 | Archie Moore | 1965 awards · 1965 postseason |
| 1965 | Billy Moran | 1965 awards · 1965 postseason |
| 1965 | Mike Jurewicz | 1965 awards · 1965 postseason |
| 1965 | Rich Beck | 1965 awards · 1965 postseason |
| 1963 | Bob Sadowski | 1963 awards · 1963 postseason |
| 1963 | Chuck Essegian | 1963 awards · 1963 postseason |
| 1963 | Corky Withrow | 1963 awards · 1963 postseason |
| 1963 | Howie Goss | 1963 awards · 1963 postseason |
| 1963 | Jack Reed | 1963 awards · 1963 postseason |
| 1963 | Norm Larker | 1963 awards · 1963 postseason |
| 1963 | Pete Smith | 1963 awards · 1963 postseason |
| 1963 | Purnal Goldy | 1963 awards · 1963 postseason |
| 1963 | Roy Gleason | 1963 awards · 1963 postseason |
| 1963 | Whitey Herzog | 1963 awards · 1963 postseason |
| 1962 | Bill Smith | 1962 awards · 1962 postseason |
| 1962 | Jim Marshall | 1962 awards · 1962 postseason |
| 1962 | Joe Bonikowski | 1962 awards · 1962 postseason |
| 1962 | Larry Foss | 1962 awards · 1962 postseason |
| 1962 | Mel Roach | 1962 awards · 1962 postseason |
| 1962 | Rogelio Alvarez | 1962 awards · 1962 postseason |
| 1961 | Jake Jacobs | 1961 awards · 1961 postseason |
| 1961 | Walt Moryn | 1961 awards · 1961 postseason |
| 1960 | Al Neiger | 1960 awards · 1960 postseason |
| 1960 | Don Choate | 1960 awards · 1960 postseason |
| 1960 | Ted Williams | 1960 awards · 1960 postseason |
| 1958 | Bob Hazle | 1958 awards · 1958 postseason |
| 1958 | Bobby Young | 1958 awards · 1958 postseason |
| 1958 | Charlie Lindstrom | 1958 awards · 1958 postseason |
| 1958 | Chuck Coles | 1958 awards · 1958 postseason |
| 1958 | Foster Castleman | 1958 awards · 1958 postseason |
| 1958 | Hal Trosky | 1958 awards · 1958 postseason |
| 1958 | John Fitzgerald | 1958 awards · 1958 postseason |
| 1958 | Lou Sleater | 1958 awards · 1958 postseason |
| 1958 | Stover McIlwain | 1958 awards · 1958 postseason |
| 1958 | Ted Kazanski | 1958 awards · 1958 postseason |
| 1958 | Walt Craddock | 1958 awards · 1958 postseason |
| 1957 | Charlie Silvera | 1957 awards · 1957 postseason |
| 1957 | Don Minnick | 1957 awards · 1957 postseason |
| 1957 | Gene Mauch | 1957 awards · 1957 postseason |
| 1957 | Joe Caffie | 1957 awards · 1957 postseason |
| 1957 | Lloyd Merritt | 1957 awards · 1957 postseason |
| 1957 | Marv Blaylock | 1957 awards · 1957 postseason |
| 1957 | Rene Valdes | 1957 awards · 1957 postseason |
| 1957 | Rod Miller | 1957 awards · 1957 postseason |
| 1957 | Ron Northey | 1957 awards · 1957 postseason |
| 1956 | Fritz Dorish | 1956 awards · 1956 postseason |
| 1956 | Toby Atwell | 1956 awards · 1956 postseason |
| 1952 | Al Federoff | 1952 awards · 1952 postseason |
| 1952 | Bob Chipman | 1952 awards · 1952 postseason |
| 1952 | Cliff Mapes | 1952 awards · 1952 postseason |
| 1952 | Clint Hartung | 1952 awards · 1952 postseason |
| 1952 | Dick Young | 1952 awards · 1952 postseason |
| 1952 | George Schmees | 1952 awards · 1952 postseason |
| 1952 | Jack Cusick | 1952 awards · 1952 postseason |
| 1952 | Jack Daniels | 1952 awards · 1952 postseason |
| 1952 | Jake Crawford | 1952 awards · 1952 postseason |
| 1952 | Ken Landenberger | 1952 awards · 1952 postseason |
| 1952 | Larry Miggins | 1952 awards · 1952 postseason |
| 1952 | Merl Combs | 1952 awards · 1952 postseason |
| 1952 | Neal Hertweck | 1952 awards · 1952 postseason |
| 1952 | Ron Necciai | 1952 awards · 1952 postseason |
| 1952 | Sonny Senerchia | 1952 awards · 1952 postseason |
| 1952 | Tom Ferrick | 1952 awards · 1952 postseason |
| 1952 | Tommy Holmes | 1952 awards · 1952 postseason |
| 1952 | Tony Bartirome | 1952 awards · 1952 postseason |
| 1951 | Aaron Robinson | 1951 awards · 1951 postseason |
| 1951 | Billy DeMars | 1951 awards · 1951 postseason |
| 1951 | Bob Dillinger | 1951 awards · 1951 postseason |
| 1951 | Irv Medlinger | 1951 awards · 1951 postseason |
| 1950 | Carlos Pascual | 1950 awards · 1950 postseason |
| 1950 | Joe Murray | 1950 awards · 1950 postseason |
| 1950 | Mickey Haefner | 1950 awards · 1950 postseason |
| 1948 | Frank Whitman | 1948 awards · 1948 postseason |
| 1948 | Lonny Frey | 1948 awards · 1948 postseason |
| 1947 | Al Gionfriddo | 1947 awards · 1947 postseason |
| 1947 | Austin Knickerbocker | 1947 awards · 1947 postseason |
| 1947 | Bennie Warren | 1947 awards · 1947 postseason |
| 1947 | Bernie Creger | 1947 awards · 1947 postseason |
| 1947 | Charlie Gilbert | 1947 awards · 1947 postseason |
| 1947 | Cookie Lavagetto | 1947 awards · 1947 postseason |
| 1947 | Dick Adams | 1947 awards · 1947 postseason |
| 1947 | Dizzy Dean | 1947 awards · 1947 postseason |
| 1947 | Ed Lyons | 1947 awards · 1947 postseason |
| 1947 | Eddie Lukon | 1947 awards · 1947 postseason |
| 1947 | Gene Handley | 1947 awards · 1947 postseason |
| 1947 | Hank Camelli | 1947 awards · 1947 postseason |
| 1947 | Lee Handley | 1947 awards · 1947 postseason |
| 1947 | Lloyd Gearhart | 1947 awards · 1947 postseason |
| 1947 | Mickey Rutner | 1947 awards · 1947 postseason |
| 1947 | Ray Mack | 1947 awards · 1947 postseason |
| 1947 | Roy Cullenbine | 1947 awards · 1947 postseason |
| 1947 | Rusty Peters | 1947 awards · 1947 postseason |
| 1947 | Sal Madrid | 1947 awards · 1947 postseason |
| 1946 | Don Grate | 1946 awards · 1946 postseason |
| 1946 | Eli Hodkey | 1946 awards · 1946 postseason |
| 1946 | Ray Flanigan | 1946 awards · 1946 postseason |
| 1946 | Ray Prim | 1946 awards · 1946 postseason |
| 1946 | Roy Hughes | 1946 awards · 1946 postseason |
| 1945 | Elmer Weingartner | 1945 awards · 1945 postseason |
| 1945 | Tom Seats | 1945 awards · 1945 postseason |
| 1944 | Albert Zachary | 1944 awards · 1944 postseason |
| 1944 | John Wells | 1944 awards · 1944 postseason |
| 1943 | Lou Ciola | 1943 awards · 1943 postseason |
| 1943 | Marv Breuer | 1943 awards · 1943 postseason |
| 1941 | Al Flair | 1941 awards · 1941 postseason |
| 1941 | Barney Olsen | 1941 awards · 1941 postseason |
| 1941 | Benny McCoy | 1941 awards · 1941 postseason |
| 1941 | Bill Harman | 1941 awards · 1941 postseason |
| 1941 | Emmett Mueller | 1941 awards · 1941 postseason |
| 1941 | Joe Marty | 1941 awards · 1941 postseason |
| 1941 | John Davis | 1941 awards · 1941 postseason |
| 1941 | Johnny Sturm | 1941 awards · 1941 postseason |
| 1941 | Lefty Grove | 1941 awards · 1941 postseason |
| 1941 | Ripper Collins | 1941 awards · 1941 postseason |
| 1941 | Soup Campbell | 1941 awards · 1941 postseason |
| 1941 | Tom Drake | 1941 awards · 1941 postseason |
| 1940 | Charlie Gelbert | 1940 awards · 1940 postseason |
| 1940 | Joe Gantenbein | 1940 awards · 1940 postseason |
| 1940 | Roxie Lawson | 1940 awards · 1940 postseason |
| 1939 | Gibby Brack | 1939 awards · 1939 postseason |
| 1939 | Hal Quick | 1939 awards · 1939 postseason |
| 1939 | Sam Page | 1939 awards · 1939 postseason |
| 1938 | Dusty Cooke | 1938 awards · 1938 postseason |
| 1938 | Ivy Andrews | 1938 awards · 1938 postseason |
| 1938 | Joe Cascarella | 1938 awards · 1938 postseason |
| 1937 | Pat Malone | 1937 awards · 1937 postseason |
| 1935 | Al Veach | 1935 awards · 1935 postseason |
| 1935 | Bill Brenzel | 1935 awards · 1935 postseason |
| 1935 | Bill Patton | 1935 awards · 1935 postseason |
| 1935 | Ernie Orsatti | 1935 awards · 1935 postseason |
| 1935 | Sad Sam Jones | 1935 awards · 1935 postseason |
| 1933 | Wilcy Moore | 1933 awards · 1933 postseason |
| 1930 | Alex Metzler | 1930 postseason |
| 1930 | Buck Crouse | 1930 postseason |
| 1930 | Curt Walker | 1930 postseason |
| 1930 | Earl Smith | 1930 postseason |
| 1930 | Guy Cantrell | 1930 postseason |
| 1930 | Hank DeBerry | 1930 postseason |
| 1930 | Homer Summa | 1930 postseason |
| 1930 | Jesse Petty | 1930 postseason |
| 1930 | Jim Galvin | 1930 postseason |
| 1930 | Jimmy Welsh | 1930 postseason |
| 1930 | John Sherlock | 1930 postseason |
| 1930 | Johnny Watson | 1930 postseason |
| 1930 | Marty Callaghan | 1930 postseason |
| 1930 | Tom Hughes | 1930 postseason |
| 1930 | Yats Wuestling | 1930 postseason |
| 1929 | Alex Gaston | 1929 awards · 1929 postseason |
| 1929 | Bob McGraw | 1929 awards · 1929 postseason |
| 1929 | George Harper | 1929 awards · 1929 postseason |
| 1929 | Jim Tennant | 1929 awards · 1929 postseason |
| 1928 | Al Wingo | 1928 awards · 1928 postseason |
| 1927 | Dick Attreau | 1927 awards · 1927 postseason |
| 1927 | Jack Tobin | 1927 awards · 1927 postseason |
| 1925 | Ernie Johnson | 1925 awards · 1925 postseason |
| 1925 | Tiny Osborne | 1925 awards · 1925 postseason |
| 1924 | Bill Cunningham | 1924 awards · 1924 postseason |
| 1924 | Buddy Crump | 1924 awards · 1924 postseason |
| 1924 | Charlie Niebergall | 1924 awards · 1924 postseason |
| 1924 | Herman Pillette | 1924 awards · 1924 postseason |
| 1924 | Hooks Cotter | 1924 awards · 1924 postseason |
| 1924 | Jimmy O'Connell | 1924 awards · 1924 postseason |
| 1924 | Pat Duncan | 1924 awards · 1924 postseason |
| 1924 | Ray Powell | 1924 awards · 1924 postseason |
| 1924 | Verne Clemons | 1924 awards · 1924 postseason |
| 1923 | Jim Sullivan | 1923 awards · 1923 postseason |
| 1922 | Charlie Eckert | 1922 awards · 1922 postseason |
| 1922 | Gus Ketchum | 1922 awards · 1922 postseason |
| 1922 | Red Schillings | 1922 awards · 1922 postseason |
| 1921 | Bob Geary | 1921 postseason |
| 1921 | Carter Elliott | 1921 postseason |
| 1921 | Harvey Freeman | 1921 postseason |
| 1921 | Ira Townsend | 1921 postseason |
| 1921 | Pete Kilduff | 1921 postseason |
| 1921 | Red Thomas | 1921 postseason |
| 1920 | Bill McKechnie | 1920 postseason |
| 1920 | Cliff Brady | 1920 postseason |
| 1919 | Al Baird | 1919 postseason |
| 1919 | Bert Adams | 1919 postseason |
| 1919 | Chick Bowen | 1919 postseason |
| 1919 | Chick Gandil | 1919 postseason |
| 1919 | Ed Gill | 1919 postseason |
| 1919 | Fred Blackwell | 1919 postseason |
| 1919 | Fritz Mollwitz | 1919 postseason |
| 1919 | Joe Schepner | 1919 postseason |
| 1919 | Joe Wilhoit | 1919 postseason |
| 1919 | Lee Magee | 1919 postseason |
| 1919 | Leo Callahan | 1919 postseason |
| 1919 | Ray Demmitt | 1919 postseason |
| 1919 | Sam Agnew | 1919 postseason |
| 1916 | Lee McElwee | 1916 postseason |
| 1915 | Bill Bradley | 1915 postseason |
| 1914 | Buck Sweeney | 1914 awards · 1914 postseason |
| 1914 | Doc Miller | 1914 awards · 1914 postseason |
| 1914 | Fred Worden | 1914 awards · 1914 postseason |
| 1914 | Toots Coyne | 1914 awards · 1914 postseason |
| 1914 | Walt Kuhn | 1914 awards · 1914 postseason |
| 1913 | Jimmy Sheckard | 1913 awards · 1913 postseason |
| 1912 | George Batten | 1912 awards · 1912 postseason |
| 1912 | Ted Goulait | 1912 awards · 1912 postseason |
| 1911 | Bugs Reisigl | 1911 awards · 1911 postseason |
| 1911 | Jerry D'Arcy | 1911 awards · 1911 postseason |
| 1911 | Otto McIvor | 1911 awards · 1911 postseason |
| 1911 | Roy Golden | 1911 awards · 1911 postseason |
| 1911 | Roy Radebaugh | 1911 awards · 1911 postseason |
| 1910 | Harry Niles | 1910 postseason |
| 1910 | Tommy Atkins | 1910 postseason |
| 1909 | Duke Reilley | 1909 postseason |
| 1907 | Joe Knotts | 1907 postseason |
| 1906 | Jim Jackson | 1906 postseason |
| 1906 | Red Donahue | 1906 postseason |
| 1903 | Benny Bowcock | 1903 postseason |
| 1903 | Eddie Quick | 1903 postseason |
| 1903 | George Magoon | 1903 postseason |
| 1903 | Harry Clark | 1903 postseason |
| 1903 | Jack Hendricks | 1903 postseason |
| 1903 | Jack O'Brien | 1903 postseason |
| 1902 | James Durham | - |
| 1901 | Bill Cristall | - |
| 1901 | George Bone | - |
| 1901 | Jim McGuire | - |
| 1901 | Joe Dolan | - |
| 1901 | Pete Dowling | - |
| 1901 | Tom Donovan | - |
| 1901 | Tommy Dowd | - |
| 1901 | William Nance | - |
| 1897 | Dave Wright | - |
| 1895 | Dick Buckley | - |
| 1895 | Ike Samuels | - |
| 1895 | John Otten | - |
| 1895 | Sam Moran | - |
| 1890 | Emmett Rogers | 1890 postseason |
| 1889 | Charlie Hoover | 1889 postseason |
| 1889 | Steve Ladew | 1889 postseason |
| 1887 | Henry Jackson | 1887 postseason |
| 1883 | Jack Jones | - |
| 1883 | John Clapp | - |
| 1882 | Amos Booth | - |
| 1877 | John Glenn | - |
| 1876 | Dave Pierson | - |
| 1875 | George Knight | - |
| 1872 | Charlie Mills | - |
